Initiating Action Research: A Review of the Challenges and Paradoxes of Opening Communicative Space

PC Gaya Wicks, P. Reason

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle (Academic Journal)

137 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

The success or failure of an action research venture often depends on what happens at the beginning of the inquiry process: in the way access is established, and on how participants and co-researchers are engaged early on. ‘Opening communicative space’ is important because, however we base our theory and practice of action research, the first steps are fateful. We draw on Habermas’s theorizing of the boundary-crises between system and lifeworld to explore the theory behind the idea of communicative space. We attempt to bring these abstract concepts to life, and to illustrate key aspects of action research practice through a review of some of the key challenges, opportunities, and paradoxes which emerge in the early stages of action research projects. Drawing on the literature and on exemplars, we show how the process of opening communicative space can be mapped onto a theory of group development that suggests a progression through phases of inclusion, control, and intimacy. Furthermore, we review an example of third-person action research to illustrate some of the issues raised by the need for both external and internal validation. We conclude that the practices of opening communicative space are necessarily paradoxical, and put forward a list of paradoxes with which facilitators and initiators of action research may need to engage in the start-up phases of their work.
Translated title of the contributionInitiating Action Research: A Review of the Challenges and Paradoxes of Opening Communicative Space
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)243 - 262
Number of pages19
JournalAction Research
Volume7(3)
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2009

Bibliographical note

This article is consistently amongst the most cited and most read articles in the Journal, and has been so ever since it was published. As of Oct 1st 2012, it is the 30th most cited article, and in the month of Sept 2012, it was the 47th most read. Google Scholar shows it as having 28 citations.

Fingerprint Dive into the research topics of 'Initiating Action Research: A Review of the Challenges and Paradoxes of Opening Communicative Space'. Together they form a unique fingerprint.

Cite this