Skip to main navigation Skip to search Skip to main content

Response to ''Comment on 'Identification of low order manifolds: Validating the algorithm of Maas and Pope'' [Chaos 16, 048101 (2006)]

  • C Rhodes
  • , M Morari
  • , S Wiggins

Research output: Contribution to journal › Article (Academic Journal) › peer-review

Abstract

Flockerzi and Heineken [Chaos 16, 048101 (2006)] present two examples with the goal of elucidating issues related to the Maas and Pope method for identifying low dimensional "slow" manifolds in systems with a time-scale separation. The goal of their first example is to show that the result claimed by Rhodes [Chaos 9, 108-123 (1999)] that the Maas and Pope algorithm identifies the slow invariant manifold in the situation in which there is finite time-scale separation is incorrect. We show that their arguments result from an incomplete understanding of the situation and that, in fact, their example supports, and is completely consistent with, the result in Rhodes . Their second example claims to be a counterexample to a conjecture in Rhodes that away from the slow manifold the criterion of Maas and Pope [Combust. Flame 88, 239-264 (1992)] will never be fulfilled. While this conjecture may indeed be false, we argue that it is not clear that the example presented by Flockerzi and Heineken is indeed a counterexample. (c) 2006 American Institute of Physics.
Translated title of the contributionResponse to ''Comment on 'Identification of low order manifolds: Validating the algorithm of Maas and Pope'' [Chaos 16, 048101 (2006)]
Original languageEnglish
JournalChaos
Volume16 (4)
Publication statusPublished - 2006

Bibliographical note

Other identifier: IDS number 121KZ

Fingerprint

Dive into the research topics of 'Response to ''Comment on 'Identification of low order manifolds: Validating the algorithm of Maas and Pope'' [Chaos 16, 048101 (2006)]'. Together they form a unique fingerprint.

Cite this