Abstract
This study is about the Korean continuous struggle for justice in the historical construction of international order from the late 19th century to the mid-20th century. As an international order is being established in East Asia, the study has reconstructed the Korea-oriented history of the international order created in East Asia through the justice in the first half of the 20th century, that is, national self-determination and the struggle for national independence. In particular, this thesis elucidates the ways in which investigates the ways in which Korea was affected by the power politics in the East Asian order based on the competition between delivering justice to Korea and their desire of maintaining the international order.Several existing studies on Korea in the field of international relations have focused on the Korean War or the origin of the peninsular partition from the realist perspective of the Cold War. Such studies, which build on the experiences of the West only to generalise the current sovereignty system, end up betraying narrowness (as in Western centrism) as they focus on the time period following the official establishment of Korea in 1945 as an independent sovereign state for the current partition of the Korean Peninsula. Moreover, they subordinate the Korean needs and/or pursuits to the interests of the United States and the former USSR and identify the former with the latter by interpreting and/or understanding the Korean experience from the perspective of those two countries.
To overcome the order-oriented understanding of the Korean Question through the Western-centric and realist Cold-War approach, this study has carried out a historical reconstruction of the Korean Question through two theoretical frameworks, that is, the expansion of European international society and the tension between order and justice in the theory of the English school. The expansion of the European international society pushes the origin of the construction of the Korean Question from after the Korean liberation earlier, to the late 19th century, thereby reconstructing the Korean Question by Korean centric perspective rather than the Western centrism. On the other hand, the framework of the tension between order and justice regards Korea as the subject in the construction of the East Asian international order through Korea’s struggle for justice such as self-determination and national independence. The study has examined the Korean Question with Korea as the subject by investigating how its pursuit of justice was sacrificed by the order constructed by powers.
To this end, this thesis focuses its examination on the four major historical junctures at which Korea's pursuit of justice was sacrificed by the reshuffle of the East Asian order to cater to the interests of world powers. 1) the voice of Korea amidst the expansion of the European international society and Japan’s annexation of Joseon, 2) the rise of nationalism amidst national self-determination and the Korean diplomacy aiming for independence and its exclusion during the interwar period, 3) the Korean anti-trusteeship movement in response to the post-war United States trusteeship plan and its failure, and 4) Korea’s attempt to create a unified government in opposition to the elections in South Korea as pushed by the world powers, its failure, and the peninsular partition. For the respective historical studies, this study has maximised its originality by citing from original documents in the four languages of Korean, Japanese, Chinese, and English, including the diplomatic documents of Korea, Japan, the US, and the UK.
None of the previous studies considered Korea’s historic struggle for independence as indispensable for the origin of the Korean War and the peninsular partition or focussed on Korea’s continued struggle for justice that pivoted on the historic construction of the international order in East Asia in the 19th and the 20th century, as they attended only to the Korean War that originated from the rivalry among the powers. This is because Korea was previously viewed as a victim and/or pawn to the rivalry among the world powers. That it has broken free from such limitations, as we view Korea’s struggle for justice through such lenses as national self-determination and independence and survey the process in which the international order was constructed in East Asia, or that it has effected a shift in the perception of Korea from that of a historical pawn to that of the subject that changes its own destiny in the international community through a historical struggle constitutes a major contribution of this study.
| Date of Award | 12 May 2022 |
|---|---|
| Original language | English |
| Awarding Institution |
|
| Supervisor | Torsten Michel (Supervisor) & Yongjin Zhang (Supervisor) |
Keywords
- English School
- East Asia
- Order
- Justice
- South Korea
Cite this
- Standard